Meredith Boe is a freelance writer and editor based in Chicago. Aside from contributing to InHerSight with insights about women in the workplace, she regularly writes literary criticism, nature articles, poetry, and creative prose.
The term “gender pay gap” is often thrown around these days, and many may think that it means men and women working the same job at the same company are paid vastly different salaries.
But, the widely cited statistic that women make 80 cents for every dollar that men make doesn’t mean that, in offices across the nation, there are men and women sitting next to each other getting paid according to that ratio.
The number comes from averaging the annual salaries of men in a given year, and dividing it by the number of males in the workforce. Then, the same thing is done for women. So nationwide, women make 80 cents to men’s dollar, across industries and professions. (Though other studies have shown this number to be much lower, more like half.)
This reality makes things much harder to pinpoint than just being able to say, I make 80 percent of what that guy sitting next to me is making. It makes it less clear who’s really to blame.
Here are just a few of the reasons that this number persists.
Women are Underrepresented in STEM Fields
The first cause of this gap is that men choose high-paying careers more than women do. Of the 25 highest paying careers for college graduates, the top 10 are all in the STEM fields: science, technology, engineering, and mathematics.
The tech world is famously dominated by men. In 2017, women made up 57 percent the workforce, but only 26 percent of professional computing positions were held by females.
And this could be getting worse. The National Center for Women and Information Technology (NCWIT) reported that in 2016, 57 percent of bachelor’s degree recipients were women, but just 19 percent of computer and information science degree recipients were women, and 18 percent of computer science degree recipients at major research universities were females. Compare that to 1985, when 37 percent of computer science bachelor’s degree recipients were women.
This number is even lower for women of color. In 2015, just 1 percent of computing occupations held by women were Hispanic, and 3 percent were African-American women.
The overall engineering field is also suffering from a lack of females entering that profession. The Bureau of Labor Statistics data shows that just 13 percent of engineers are female.
According to the US Department of Labor, the most common career for women is an elementary school teacher, followed by registered nurse and receptionist/administrative assistant. But even within the teaching and nursing professions, the women’s average weekly earnings compared to men’s is 88.9 percent and 89.9 percent, respectively.
So, clearly the gap can’t just be explained by women not choosing the right career paths. It exists even within the careers that women dominate.
Women Leave Their Jobs More Often Than Men
Another reason that the gender pay gap persists is because women more commonly leave their jobs or take a break from their career advancement. This could be to have children or to pursue a different career path all together.
For example, only 30 percent of women who receive bachelor’s degrees in engineering are still working in the field 20 years later. And, 56 percent of women in the technology field reportedly left their jobs after 10 to 20 years in the careers. In the high-tech industry, the quit rate for men is 17 percent and for women it’s 41 percent.
The Institute for Women’s Policy Research released data showing that women are nearly twice as likely as men to take time off work—at least a year—and that these women earn an average of 39 percent less than men.
Also, as NCWIT says, when job satisfaction is low, underrepresented groups such as women or minorities will change careers to find a more fulfilling and comfortable work experience.
Women may not be in the most high-paying roles because of negative workplace experiences. These include harassment, intimidation, or even a lack of females in leadership roles paving the way for young women.
In the technology field, NCWIT says the discrepancy in salaries can arise because females are more encouraged to take on execution-type roles instead of the creator roles that generally pay more.
Women also feel like they have to prove they are capable more than their male coworkers do, and this can be intimidating, diverting women further. It’s not very appealing to have to put in that extra work just to feel like an equal. The Society of Women Engineers research shows that 61 percent of female engineers reported they have to continue to prove themselves to reach the same level of respect and recognition as their male counterparts.
These issues are extremely complex and hard to solve. The gender pay gap has a complicated, multifaceted origin, and there’s no simple answer that will fix it.
What we can do is spread the word and encourage more young women to enter careers they are passionate about, even if they’re male-dominated. And perhaps more importantly, we can continue educating men about these issues so they become more mindful advocates for female success (and will submit to our eventual world domination).
This article is part of InHerSight’s month-long coverage of equal pay. Timed with Equal Pay Day, the series looks at how the pay gap affects women of all backgrounds and in all industries.